We have put together some challenging Harry Potter would you rather questions. Some of them will be fun, like asking you which character that you would want to be close friends with. Some of them will be tough, like asking you which magical creature that you would rather fight (if you had to choose of course). The idea is to give you some fun questions to challenge yourself and your friends with. Let’s get to it.
Harry Potter Would You Rather Questions
1) Attend Ilvermorny School of Witchcraft and Wizardry Or Attend Beauxbatons Academy of Magic?
Ilvermorny is the American Wizarding school that will be featured in Fantastic Beasts and Beauxbatons is the French Wizarding school that was featured in Goblet of Fire.
2) Play As A Chaser In Quidditch Or Play As A Goalkeeper In Quidditch?
The Chaser attempts to score goals with the quaffle and the goalkeeper tries to stop the quaffle from going into the net.
3) Be Best Friends With Luna Lovegood Or Be Best Friends With Neville Longbottom?
Both would make for interesting friendships and both are two of Harry Potter’s best friends.
4) Be In Ravenclaw House or Be In Hufflepuff House?
Choose between two of the lesser-talked about houses in the series.
5) Be Best Friends With Ron Weasley Or Be Best Friends With Hermione Granger?
Wand (gun) to your head and you have to pick one, who do you choose?
6) Attend The Quidditch World Cup or Attend The Triwizard Tournament?
Both would be a lot of fun to watch, depending on your taste.
7) Face The Basilisk From The Chamber Of Secrets Or Face Aragog?
This one depends on if you hate spiders or snakes more. A tough one for those who hate both (like myself).
8) Attend Defense Against The Dark Arts Class Or Attend Care Of Magical Creatures Class?
Defense Against The Dark Arts would teach you a bunch of cool spells. Care of Magical Creatures would allow you to meet some awesome magical creatures.
9) Visit The Hogwarts Library Or Visit The Hogwarts Astronomy Tower?
Both are two unique places at Hogwarts that many people would love to explore.
10) Have Hagrid As Your Professor Or Have McGonagall As Your Professor?
Both have different teaching styles and teach different courses (Care of Magical Creatures for Hagrid and Transfiguration for McGonagall).
11) A New TV Show Adaptation Of The Harry Potter Universe Or One More Harry Potter Movie With The Old Cast?
Can we have both please? If you had to choose one, what would it be?
12) Shop At Ollivanders Or Shop At Weasleys’ Wizard Wheezes?
Get your own wand or get some funny practical joke stuff from your favorite Wizarding Family.
13) Shop At Magical Menagerie Or Shop At Flourish and Blotts?
Magical Menagerie sells magical creatures like owls, ravens, and cats. Flourish and Blotts sells Wizarding books.
14) Spend A Day With Daniel Radcliffe Or Spend A Day With Emma Watson?
Both would have fantastic stories about their careers and experiences on the Harry Potter set.
15) Spend A Single Day In Azkaban Prison Or Spend A Week Living In The Forbidden Forest?
Both punishments sound bad. Would would you pick if you had to choose?
16) Fight A Dementor Or Fight A Troll?
Both seem like tough opponents.
17) Have An Invisibility Cloak Or Have The Elder Wand?
Two of the three Deathly Hallows. One grants you invisibility whenever you want it, the other is the most powerful wand to exist.
18) Play Quidditch Or Play Wizard’s Chess?
Both would be fun but dangerous.
19) Be Best Friends With Harry Potter & Ginny Weasley’s Child Or Be Best Friend’s With Ron Weasley & Hermione Granger’s Child?
Which Student would you like to attend Hogwarts with?
20) Be An Auror Or Be A Magizoologist?
An Auror fights and hunts dark Witches and Wizards. A Magizoologist studies and works with magical creatures.
21) Had Ron Weasley Die During The Movies Or Had Hagrid Die During The Series?
Both are two of the most beloved characters in the entire series.
22) Have Dolores Umbridge As Your Professor Or Have Bellatrix Lestrange As Your Aunt?
Two of the biggest female villains in the series. You would have to work very closely with the Professor. The Aunt would be at family events though.
23) Have Had Sirius Black Survive The Series Or Have Had Fred Weasley Survive The Series?
A choice between two of the saddest deaths in the entire series.
24) Live With The Dursley Family For 6 Months Or Live With Dolores Umbridge For A Full Week?
Living with Umbridge would be worse but it would only be for a week.
25) Have An Owl As Your Pet At Hogwarts Or Have A Cat As Your Pet At Hogwarts?
Essentially, would you want Crookshanks or Hedwig as your sidekick at Hogwarts?
26) Never Watch The Harry Potter Movies Again Or Never Read The Books Again?
A true books vs movies debate. What would you lose if you HAD to choose?
27) Hang Out With Xenophilius Lovegood For A Day Or Get Interviewed By Rita Skeeter?
Lovegood would probably talk your ear off for the entire day. Rita would ask you some hard-hitting questions that you might not want to answer.
28) Dance With Your Crush At The Yule Ball Or Attend The Wedding Of Bill Weasley And Fleur Delacour
One would be the romantic option. The other would be the option where you can cross paths with some big names in the Wizarding World.
29) Hang Out With Tom Felton For A Day Or Hang Out With Rupert Grint For A Day?
Would you want to hang out with the actor who played Draco Malfoy or Ron Weasley? Both would have some great stories to tell and seem like awesome guys.
Speaking of both guys, make sure to check out our ultimate Harry Potter birthday list, where you can see when the cast and characters were born.
30) Have Filius Flitwick As Your Professor Or Have Severus Snape As Your Professor?
Snape’s would be the tougher class but you would get to hang out with a true hero from the series.
Do you have any good Harry Potter Would You Rather questions for us? We would love to hear about them in the comment section below.
If you enjoyed this, make sure to check out our Harry Potter Alphabet using the names of characters.